Shop

Gift

Learn

ABOUT

JOIN THE CLUB Account

+ FREE SHIPPING OVER £50

+ JOIN THE CLUB FOR JUST £15

Home
Blog
Portokalopita (Greek orange phyllo cake)

Portokalopita (Greek orange phyllo cake)

Sweet seasonal oranges, a pouring of EVOO, filo pastry, and thick, creamy Greek yogurt are combined and soaked in a fragrant orange syrup for a sweet, juicy, and oh-so-succulent slice.

This is the third and final recipe from Helena Moursellas. Helena is a bestselling cookbook author and chef who, alongside her twin sister Vikki, is sharing her love for Greek food with the world. She blends culinary expertise with creativity and a deep appreciation for her Thessalonkian heritage to create delicious, accessible recipes.

Portokalopita translates to ‘orange pie’ and is a traditional Greek cake from the island of Crete. Less pie, more cake, this is the perfect end to an Easter meal. Or, save it for a teatime treat later. The key to this is the orange syrup, which the cake “drinks up”, so don’t be tempted to skimp on this part. Pour it over and then let the cake sit for at least 15 minutes as the syrup oozes into every layer.

“This is my favourite,” expresses Helena. And we can see why.

Just don’t forget Yiayia Koula’s golden rule: hot syrup cold cake, or cold syrup hot cake.

Here's the method:

Feeds 6-8.

Preheat the oven to 120°C.
In a large deep baking dish, place 1 filo sheet at a time in the tray
scrunching inwards from the long side.
Repeat with all filo sheets.
Place into the oven for 30 minutes. Scrunching every 10 minutes.
Remove from the oven and cool filo pieces before adding to the cake batter.
Scrunch the pastry in fine pieces once more, making sure all the pastry is dry and crushed.
Grease and line the base and side of a round 20cm cake tin with baking paper.
To make the orange syrup, place all ingredients and 250 ml (1 cup) water into a small saucepan over high heat and bring to the boil.
Reduce the heat to low and simmer for 15 minutes or until reduced by half and syrupy. Set aside to cool completely.
Increase the oven temperature to 160°C.
Place the eggs and sugar in the bowl of a stand mixer attached with the paddle attachment and beat for 3-5 minutes or until light and creamy.
Fold through the oil, yoghurt, orange zest and baking powder and stir through the dried filo. Pour into the prepared tin.
Bake for 1 hour or until a skewer comes out clean. Poke tiny holes into the cake and pour the orange syrup over the hot cake.
Leave the cake for 1 hour to absorb the syrup.
Slice and serve with extra yoghurt and olive oil.

Join the Olive Oil Club

We travel the world to seek out remarkable independent producers, sourcing some of the best olive oils out there. For a revolving selection of exclusive, small batch EVOOs...

SHOP NOW

You may also like...

Aubergine, tomato, and kalamata olives.

Silky aubergine, tomato, and red wine vinegar are balanced by the natural sweetness of dates and slow-cooked red onion and made to shine with plenty of September’s Club drop from Córdoba. This vibrant bowl from Kali Jago is the perfect dish to help your transition into autumn. Sweet, succulent tomato brings a taste of summer and this hearty Mediterranean dish will sit happily in the fridge for a few days, so it’s an ideal batch cook to set you up for the week. Plus, you can bulk it out with ...

Cherry pavlova with olive oil

Tangy yoghurt cream, crunchy pistachios, crisp meringue, and juicy cherries—these single-serve pavlovas are a sweet sensation for eyes and taste buds alike. Take your pavlova up a notch with the addition of extra virgin olive oil. An extra drizzle of our Greek olive oil or August’s Portuguese Club EVOO is the ideal pairing to cut through the sweetness and adds a shine of gold to this dessert. Purple fruits are also packed with polyphenols, adding even more goodness. If you don’t have fresh ...

Ceramics for the Olive Oil Club

From Porto to pride of place in the kitchen, one of your most requested products—the Citizens of Soil ceramic—is here. Within months of us launching in 2021, people kept telling us how they’d love to have our oil in a nice ceramic. At events and tastings, customers would ask about the best way to store their oil and show us different vessels they had used to refill our signature pouches. When you make a normal glass olive oil bottle as pretty as ours—it’s natural that people want to see what...

FAQs about olive oil brands and quality

They certainly can be! But it’s always important to consider why they’re expensive. If the higher price reflects early harvest olives, small-batch production, regenerative farming, and fair wages for farmers, then yes – you're likely getting a high-quality product that’s better for your health, the environment, and the industry. But sometimes, the price tag just reflects good branding and fancy packaging. Always look for real indicators of quality like harvest date, origin transparency, proper packaging, and clear production practices to know if it’s truly worth the splurge.
The best way to tell if you have a bottle of real extra virgin olive oil—and not just labeled that way—is to look for transparency and pay close attention to the details. Quality EVOO will list a harvest date (not just an expiration date), come in a dark glass or tin container, and specify the origin. Avoid vague blends and flashy marketing claims without substance. And most importantly, taste it: legitimate extra virgin olive oil should be fruity, bitter and peppery—not flat or greasy. Your palate is often the best judge
One of the biggest culprits is the term ‘first cold pressed’, which might sound impressive but doesn't define the modern extra virgin olive oil making process or the product's quality. Also look for the harvest date. If you only see an expiration or “best before”, it's more likely the olive oil quality isn't as good. Also pay attention to vague origins like ‘EU blend’. While this might sound romantic, it's a strong indicator that olive oil quality is not top notch. Long story short: true quality comes from transparency, not trendy marketing, so always look beyond branding.