extra virgin olive oil ice cream

Olive oil ice cream from the Michelin-starred Cornerstone team

Though the pairing ice cream with extra virgin olive oil might sound strange at first—it is the best thing ever. The olive oil makes the ice cream somehow even more creamy, smooth, and decadent.

We've been singing the praises of this combo for a while now, and testing in loads of ways. Typically this has been some store-bought vanilla ice cream with some sea salt flakes over the top. We've also tried it with a range of Hackney Gelato, and even gone vegan. Like magic, the texture of the olive oil takes your standard vegan ice cream to new lush heights.

But then the absolute dream-team that is Head Chef James Toth and the insanely-talented Pastry Chef Laura Petersen from Hackney's Michelin-starred Cornerstone gifted us with this very special recipe.

Here they detail how to make olive oil ice cream from scratch using our single estate EVOO from Crete just like they do at Cornerstone. 

And while it might require a little bit more effort than picking up a tub of ice cream at a local grocer, this tastes worlds better and should become a staple of your next dinner party—regardless of the season!

    Here's the method:

    Serves 8-10

    • In a pan, bring the milk to a simmer with the glucose.
    • Whisk the yolks with the sugar together in a bowl.
    • Once the milk has simmered, pour it onto the egg yolk mix and whisk until combined.
    • Pour the custard back into a clean pan and cook until it coats the back of a spoon. (Exactly 82 degrees celsius if you have a probe.)
    • Take off the heat.
    • In a slow and steady stream pour in the olive oil while whisking the mix and add the salt.
    • Strain through a sieve to make the mix super smooth.
    • Churn in an ice cream machine for the best results. Alternatively, freeze in a container stirring every hour.
    • Enjoy with an extra drizzle of extra virgin olive oil and a sprinkle of salt.

     

    Ways to make it your own:

     

    • Playing around with the flavour combinations such as basil or mint.
    • Crushing in some fresh citrus or serving it in citrus "shells".


    Are you making this? Share with your fellow citizens. Tag us in your photos on Instagram at @CitizensofSoil.

    Join the Olive Oil Club™

  • Sourced by an olive oil sommelier.
  • Exclusive oils every month.
  • Free shipping, always.
  • Skip, cancel, or add more anytime.
  • SHOP NOW

    You may also like...

    How to host with Sophia Pelizzoli

    Sophia Pelizzoli is a chef and ceramicist, in that order. She says she designs ceramics as “a beautiful excuse to lay the table and create memories with those who matter most.” From intimate dinners at home, to supper clubs at GAIL's, hosting for Sophia is both a job and a joy.  Her shelves are stacked with cookbooks and she pulls one out in particular: Diana Henry’s “How to Eat a Peach”, a recipe book that can be read like a novel. Henry does not write isolated recipes, she embeds them int...


    No-churn olive oil ice cream

    Extra virgin olive oil adds a rich creaminess to this simple, no-churn ice cream recipe. Finish with a further drizzle of EVOO and a pinch of flakey sea salt for a dessert that will keep your guests coming back for more.  When hosting, “there’s something nice about tying the beginning and end together,” says Sophia Pelizzoli, chef and creator of this recipe. Extra virgin olive oil is her golden touch; a single ingredient threaded through the menu for a memorable evening.  Here's the method...


    How to host with Max Hurd

    An entrancing home, with hundreds of things to look at, it could take you years to fully appreciate all of Max’s little touches. What better person to take us through how he hosts, than a man whose modus operandi is abundance? Max Hurd’s London home appears from the outside to be a classic Victorian terrace. But inside, the interiors and possessions of a large country house have arranged themselves over a much smaller space. In colour drenched rooms filled with books, antiques and painting...