Ice cream with olive oil - extra virgin single estate from Citizens of Soil

Olive oil and ice cream—it's a thing.

Introducing the breakthrough sensation that made us question: “What *can’t* you put EVOO on?”

Last summer, in a brief moment of hiatus of the London lockdown, we sat down at Michael's very favourite restaurant—Quality Chop House in Farringdon. 

They absolutely smash every meal, and this one was no different. Already head-down in trying to bring our olive oil business to life, this dessert stood out on the menu.

Bold in its simplicity. Proud in its pairing. Intriguing in its coveted place on such a short list.

But we'd heard rave reviews, both inside the olive oil world and within the foodie space, of olive oil on ice cream being a thing.

Olive oil ice cream at London's Quality Chop House restaurant

One bite—mind blown.

So once we finished harvest in Crete last autumn and brought back a bottle of our very own extra virgin olive oil, we could hardly wait to pour it over some ice cream and see if the pairing worked.

Note: Olive oils, like wine, come in many varieties and styles. Some are sweeter, greener, more bitter or have flavours that mean they wouldn't compliment a crazy mix like being used a top a creamy dessert. 

And yet, it worked. Michael was smitten. It became his new favourite thing (just maaaaybe even beating out an olive oil martini—but that's for another post).

Which bring us to this signature serve we're now owning...

  • Plain ice cream (we like vanilla*)
  • Cocoa nibs (a tablespoon per serving of ice cream)
  • Sea salt (a pinch per serving)
  • Single estate extra virgin olive oil (ours is killer here!)

The amount of EVOO depends on you. We like to pour it like we would chocolate syrup, but if you're hesitant in the first go—about 1-2 tablespoons per serving would suit.

*We prefer it over plain vanilla, but we’ve also used Hackney Gelato's pistachio, almond & lemon (though surprisingly preferred it on their butterscotch), as well as Booja Booja's chocolate and Jude's clotted cream.

See our attempt at TikTok here with a tribute to summer. Needless to say, we've turned this pairing obsession into a lifestyle. 

Join the Olive Oil Club™

  • Sourced by an olive oil sommelier.
  • Exclusive oils every month.
  • Free shipping, always.
  • Skip, cancel, or add more anytime.
  • SHOP NOW

    You may also like...

    How to host with Sophia Pelizzoli

    Sophia Pelizzoli is a chef and ceramicist, in that order. She says she designs ceramics as “a beautiful excuse to lay the table and create memories with those who matter most.” From intimate dinners at home, to supper clubs at GAIL's, hosting for Sophia is both a job and a joy.  Her shelves are stacked with cookbooks and she pulls one out in particular: Diana Henry’s “How to Eat a Peach”, a recipe book that can be read like a novel. Henry does not write isolated recipes, she embeds them int...


    No-churn olive oil ice cream

    Extra virgin olive oil adds a rich creaminess to this simple, no-churn ice cream recipe. Finish with a further drizzle of EVOO and a pinch of flakey sea salt for a dessert that will keep your guests coming back for more.  When hosting, “there’s something nice about tying the beginning and end together,” says Sophia Pelizzoli, chef and creator of this recipe. Extra virgin olive oil is her golden touch; a single ingredient threaded through the menu for a memorable evening.  Here's the method...


    How to host with Max Hurd

    An entrancing home, with hundreds of things to look at, it could take you years to fully appreciate all of Max’s little touches. What better person to take us through how he hosts, than a man whose modus operandi is abundance? Max Hurd’s London home appears from the outside to be a classic Victorian terrace. But inside, the interiors and possessions of a large country house have arranged themselves over a much smaller space. In colour drenched rooms filled with books, antiques and painting...